Value Pool

A value pool is a part of a market or ecosystem where economic value concentrates, measured as revenue, profit or expected future profit. Mapping value pools shows where the money sits across activities, which a market’s total size hides.

Key factors

  • Profit differs from revenue. Gadiesh and Gilbert showed profit is uneven across value-chain stages, and within each stage by customer, product, region and channel. The largest revenue pool may earn little.
  • A stated measure. Value pool is used loosely, so each analysis should say whether it counts revenue, profit, margin or expected future value.
  • Contestable control points. A large pool behind an interface, standard or data asset that one firm controls is closed to others. The useful targets are pools whose control points are still open.
  • Migration triggers. Value moves when end customers or their needs change, or when a complement erodes an incumbent’s added value.

Examples

U-Haul. In early-1990s US truck rental, Gadiesh and Gilbert found U-Haul barely broke even on rentals yet earned an operating margin of about 10%, against an industry average below 3%. The profit came from boxes, insurance, trailers and storage, where customers stopped shopping around. The storage pool has kept growing: in the year to March 2025 U-Haul’s self-storage revenue rose 8% to about $898 million, alongside $3.7 billion from equipment rental.

Telus. The Canadian telecoms operator looked beyond connectivity to workplace and digital health. It bought the employee-wellbeing firm LifeWorks for C$2.3 billion in September 2022 and merged it into Telus Health. By the end of 2024 Telus Health covered 76.2 million lives, and its revenue grew 10% in the fourth quarter. Telus reached a new value pool by stretching its existing customer relationships and networks into an adjacent sector.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a value pool and a profit pool?

A profit pool is the total profit earned at each stage of an industry’s value chain. Value pool is the looser term consultants use for concentrations of revenue, profit or future opportunity.

How does a value pool relate to value capture?

A value pool is a property of the system: where value accumulates. Value capture is the share a particular participant secures from it, which depends on scarcity, control points and bargaining power.

Who introduced profit pool analysis?

The consultants Orit Gadiesh and James Gilbert set it out in two Harvard Business Review articles in 1998. They showed managers that the biggest sources of revenue were often not the most profitable.

How do you map value pools in an ecosystem?

Start from the customer outcome and list the activities needed to deliver it. Estimate the size and margin of each, then ask what could move value and who controls access to it.

Related concepts

Value Capture
Ecosystem Control Point
Ecosystem Bottleneck
Ecosystem Business Model